Decision calculator

Repair your car or replace it?

Start with four numbers, then check the cost assumptions before relying on the estimate.

Car on a mountain road, representing the repair-or-replace decision
This is a cost comparison, not a verdict.

Safety, reliability, downtime, convenience, and how much you value the vehicle can still change the decision.

Try a worked example ("Repair", "New Car", or "Financially Close" Results)

Illustrative scenarios, not price quotes. Loading an example replaces all inputs and assumptions; you can edit them afterwards.

Repair example

Current car value: $8,000 · Repair needed now: $2,500 · Replacement vehicle price: $30,000 · Compare over: 3 years

New car example

Current car value: $8,000 · Repair needed now: $9,000 · Replacement vehicle price: $30,000 · Compare over: 3 years

Financially close example

Current car value: $8,000 · Repair needed now: $5,700 · Replacement vehicle price: $30,000 · Compare over: 3 years

Step 1

Quick comparison

These four numbers get you to a useful first estimate.

Start here

Values shown are editable example defaults. Change them to match your situation.

$2,500
$30,000
Jump to current result ↓

Results

Example comparison - replace the starting values with your own.

Compares modeled costs over the same period. Monthly equivalents are not loan payments.

Starting assumptions are included.

Review cost assumptions
Live result Updates automatically as you change the numbers

Comparison unavailable

If the comparison does not load, reload the page or read the guide.

Repair + keep — —
Replace now — —
Estimated difference —

Your break-even point

Repair breakeven — The repair amount where the estimated costs become equal.
What could change the result?
What changes the answer? Calculate a comparison to see what changes the answer.

How stable is this result?

—

Stress test: a repair-favorable case, the base case, and a replacement-favorable case.

See the math

—

Step 2

Cost assumptions (optional)

Fine-tune maintenance, resale value, financing, fees, and fuel savings.

Current car end value: — Replacement end value: — Maintenance: —
Review assumptions

The quick estimate starts with example assumptions. Review these before relying on the result, especially for a major purchase.

Current car

Replacement vehicle

Why these defaults? Source notes and assumptions · How defaults work

How to interpret the result →
What this comparison includes and leaves out

Other factors in your decision

This model compares the financial paths you enter. Safety, code requirements, warranty coverage, reliability, downtime, financing constraints, and unusual installation conditions can outweigh a small modeled cost difference.

What's included

Repair cost, maintenance/repairs, depreciation, taxes/fees, financing, future values, and optional fuel/energy savings.

What's not

Investment returns, insurance differences, exact future repair probabilities, or a made-up dollar value for safety and convenience.

Best practice

Run an optimistic and pessimistic scenario. If the answer flips easily, the dollar difference is not decisive.

How to interpret the estimate

These estimates are undiscounted: they do not model inflation, the time value of money, or every future failure. Monthly equivalents divide modeled cost across the period; they are not loan payments. Read the scope and exclusions for each model.

Resolve safety concerns with a qualified professional before comparing cost. Confirm quote scope, eligibility for incentives, and expected service life.