How our decision models work

The goal is not to tell you what to do. The goal is to make the tradeoff visible, checkable, and easy to stress-test.

The 10 rules

  1. Compare equivalent paths. Use the same horizon, or explain an annualized method.
  2. Count costs that actually change. Avoid double-counting sunk costs.
  3. Label defaults. Example values are starting points, not facts.
  4. Keep close calls close. Small modeled gaps should not become confident verdicts.
  5. Stress-test the answer. Change the assumptions most likely to flip the result.
  6. Show the math. Users should be able to audit the model.
  7. Separate money from values. Safety, reliability, downtime, and convenience can outweigh modeled cost.
  8. Prefer durable sources. Use primary or authoritative sources where possible.
  9. Test the model. Base cases and edge cases must pass before release.
  10. State what the model is not. A calculator is not an inspection, prediction, quote, or guarantee.

What “lower modeled cost” means

It means one path costs less inside the assumptions and time horizon shown on that calculator. It is not a claim that the path is safer, more reliable, more convenient, or universally better.

Source quality

We prioritize evidence in this order when it fits the question:

  1. Primary / government: agency rules, official programs, technical standards, required disclosures.
  2. Manufacturer or utility documentation: model-specific performance, installation needs, rate schedules.
  3. Established technical or consumer references: useful when primary data is incomplete.
  4. Editorial estimates: clearly labeled and editable; never treated as universal facts.

What “How stable is this result?” means

It is not a probability forecast or confidence score. It asks whether a small set of reasonable alternative assumptions changes which path has the lower modeled cost. A 2-of-3 result is a warning that the decision is assumption-sensitive.

How defaults are maintained

Defaults exist to make a calculator usable before you have every number. They are labeled, editable, and should be replaced with your quote, rate, equipment estimate, resale value, or model-specific information whenever possible.

See assumption and model-change history →

What we deliberately do not fake

We do not turn uncertain future failures into precise probabilities without evidence. We do not hardcode temporary rebates as if every user qualifies. We do not assign invented dollar values to safety, comfort, stress, or downtime simply to force a numerical answer.

Release standard

Before a calculator ships, its math must pass regression tests, required page elements must exist, internal links must resolve, mobile structure must remain usable, and public files must pass a privacy scan. See the project launch checklist for the full release process.

Editorial accountability

Our sourcing, correction, review, and monetization standards are public.

Read Editorial Standards & Corrections →

Quick repair threshold resource

For a simplified first-pass check before using a full calculator, use the transparent repair-vs.-replace threshold table.

Open the Repair vs. Replace Threshold Table →

What each model counts

All current models use editable example inputs. Repair and equipment models compare undiscounted costs or simple annualized costs; they do not calculate detailed financing schedules, failure probabilities, or guaranteed service life. The rent-versus-buy model calculates a fixed-rate mortgage schedule and projects housing costs, home value, and investments in future nominal dollars using your growth assumptions. It does not adjust ending wealth for inflation or discount it to today’s dollars. These scenarios are estimates, not forecasts or guarantees. Close results should prompt a review of assumptions.

Current model scope and important exclusions
ModelComparisonImportant exclusions
CarSame horizon: repair, maintenance, depreciation, replacement fees and total interest, and fuel savings.Original purchase price is sunk. No discounting or detailed loan schedule; fuel savings are a difference between paths.
ApplianceRepair cost divided by added life plus yearly operation; replacement plus extras divided by expected life plus yearly operation.Simple annualization, rather than discounted equivalent annual cost. No probability of another failure or guaranteed lifespan.
HVAC repairSame horizon: repaired operation until assumed failure, then full replacement cost and replacement operation if failure occurs within the horizon.No remaining-value credit at the horizon or repeated replacement cycles. Delayed replacement uses the entered current quote and incentives.
Heat pump versus furnaceSame delivered heating load, net installation, heating energy and maintenance over the selected horizon.No cooling energy difference, backup heat, fixed gas fees, resale credit or future replacements. Add relevant electrical work to quotes and optional AC cost to furnace scope.
Water heaterSame horizon: repair plus future repair allowance; full chosen replacement after repaired life ends within the horizon; installation and yearly operation for each path.No remaining-value credit or repeated replacement cycles. Future replacement uses entered current quotes and incentives.
Rent versus buyMonthly mortgage balance, ownership costs, rent, investing the difference on either path, and sale proceeds at the chosen horizon.Illustrative editable assumptions. No income-tax deductions, investment taxes, capital-gains taxes, inflation-adjusted dollars, or unmodeled major repairs. PMI uses the model's simplified original-value rule; actual loan terms differ.

For repair and equipment calculators, monthly equivalents are modeled totals divided by months, not financing offers. The housing model shows a calculated mortgage payment and compares ending wealth. Incentives must be personally verified; the model floors net installation at zero.