Quick answer

Buying can build equity and give you control over your home. Renting can keep money available and make moving easier. Neither wins at every price or over every time period.

Use the calculator to compare estimated ending wealth. Then check whether the monthly cost, cash needed up front, and risk work for you.

Compare wealth, cash flow, and flexibility

A mortgage payment and a rent payment tell only part of the story. A down payment becomes home equity, while closing costs pay for the transaction. Paying down principal reduces a debt. Interest, taxes, insurance, and repairs use cash without paying down that debt.

The renter can invest the cash that the buyer uses for a down payment and purchase closing costs. Either household can also invest a monthly housing-cost advantage. That only happens if the money is actually saved. If you would spend it instead, the investment assumption does not describe your plan.

Our calculator gives both paths the same starting cash. Each month, the household with lower modeled housing costs invests the difference. At your selected move date, it compares the renter's investment account with the buyer's estimated sale proceeds plus any investment account.

Buyer ending wealth = home value − sale costs − remaining mortgage + invested savings
Renter ending wealth = invested starting cash + invested monthly savings and returns

Those are modeled housing-related assets, not your entire net worth. A result that favors buying does not mean the purchase is affordable. A result that favors renting does not put a price on having control of your home.

Gather numbers for homes you would actually choose

Start with a purchase price, comparable monthly rent, down payment, quoted mortgage rate, and expected years before moving. A smaller rental and a larger purchased home can be a valid lifestyle choice, but the cost gap then reflects both tenure and the extra housing.

  • Loan and purchase costs: use a written Loan Estimate. Keep the down payment separate from purchase closing costs. Do not enter the full cash-to-close amount as closing costs or count prepaid taxes and insurance twice. The CFPB Closing Disclosure explainer helps separate these amounts.
  • Ongoing ownership: gather property tax, insurance, mortgage insurance, HOA dues, and a maintenance allowance. The CFPB home budget guide also calls out utilities, repairs, and emergency savings. Compare those extra costs outside the calculator when the homes differ.
  • Renting: use the actual lease rent and renters insurance. Check parking, pet fees, utilities, deposits, and moving costs separately. A refundable deposit ties up cash; it is not automatically a permanent expense.
  • Future sale: ask for a local estimate of selling costs. Include the costs relevant to your planned sale; do not treat a sample percentage as a required commission.
  • Future growth: home appreciation, rent growth, and investment returns are assumptions. Use several plausible cases rather than one number you hope will happen.

Every prefilled value is an illustrative starting point. It is not a current mortgage quote, local price forecast, or promise about returns.

Use the calculator in three passes

  1. Enter today's facts. Use your price, lease, down payment, loan quote, and likely holding period.
  2. Review the assumptions. Replace sample costs and growth rates. Check what the model leaves out below.
  3. Stress-test the result. Try an earlier move, weaker home appreciation, and a different investment return. Then test slower rent growth or higher maintenance.

The calculator labels a result financially close when the gap is no more than the larger of $1,000 or 2% of the smaller absolute ending-wealth estimate. That is an editorial comparison band, not a measure of forecast accuracy.

A result that flips after a small change deserves less confidence. If the difference is financially close, liquidity, location, maintenance work, and the chance of moving may matter more than the modeled gap.

Try three illustrative cases

These links load editable sample inputs, not local quotes. Each case uses a $400,000 home, 20% down, and a 6.5% fixed mortgage rate, along with the calculator's other sample assumptions. Review every input before using a result.

These are different scenarios. They are not evidence that a particular rent or holding period always produces that result.

There is no universal break-even year

Buying and later selling creates transaction costs. Staying longer gives the model more time for equity, rent growth, and investment returns to change the comparison. That does not guarantee buying will catch up.

The calculator checks the wealth gap each month. The main break-even result shows when buying moves ahead and stays ahead through your selected horizon. The paths can change lead more than once, so this may differ from their first crossover. It does not promise that buying stays ahead beyond that horizon.

If no sustained buying lead appears, buying did not remain ahead through that horizon. Change the horizon and assumptions to test the result. An early forced sale can also make a long-term buying plan a poor fit.

Keep tax savings out until you can support them

This calculator assumes no income-tax savings from buying. The IRS mortgage-interest guidance requires itemizing and other conditions for a deduction. A deduction is not a dollar-for-dollar refund, and your added tax benefit depends on your full return.

It also leaves out investment taxes and tax on a home sale. If taxes could change a close result, compare both paths using tax advice for your situation before acting.

Understand the model before trusting the result

The calculator uses a fixed-rate mortgage with monthly payments. It pays down the balance until payoff. Home values and rent grow monthly at the effective rates implied by your annual assumptions. Investments earn the same assumed return in both paths, with monthly savings added after that month's growth.

Property tax and maintenance are modeled as percentages of the changing home value. Homeowners insurance, HOA dues, and renters insurance stay at the entered amounts. This is a simplifying choice; actual bills can change differently.

The model assumes a fixed-rate conventional loan with borrower-paid PMI and payments kept current. PMI stops at the scheduled 78% balance threshold or after the loan midpoint. It uses the purchase price as original value; actual original value may be lower if the appraisal is lower. It does not model requested early cancellation at 80%, FHA mortgage insurance, VA fees, or lender-paid insurance. The CFPB PMI cancellation guide explains these differences. Check your loan’s terms.

All results use future dollars without an inflation adjustment. The model does not include refinancing, adjustable rates, extra principal payments, taxes on returns or sale proceeds, one-time renovations, special assessments, different utility bills, or refundable deposits. A maintenance allowance spreads spending across months; it cannot tell you when a roof will fail.

The result assumes a sale at the chosen horizon, including the selling-cost percentage you enter. Equity is not the same as cash available today. The model does not test mortgage approval, emergency reserves, or your ability to fund a large surprise bill.

When the lower modeled cost is not the better choice

Buying may fit a household that values a stable location and wants responsibility for the property. Renting may fit someone who needs to move quickly or wants fewer repair duties. Think about job changes, accessibility, commute, school fit, and the cash you need for other goals. These tradeoffs belong in the decision even though the calculator does not score them.

Common questions

Is renting throwing money away?

Rent pays for a place to live. Owners also pay costs that do not build equity. Compare the full paths and what you do with the money left over.

Should I buy if the mortgage payment is below rent?

Check taxes, insurance, HOA, maintenance, purchase and sale costs, and the down payment's alternative use. A lower loan payment alone does not settle the question.

Does a larger down payment always help?

It reduces borrowing but leaves less money available for investments or emergencies. Compare both the modeled wealth and the cash you would have left.

What if I stay much longer than planned?

Run that holding period too. Also run an earlier move. A plan that works only if you stay for decades may be too fragile for your circumstances.

Can I use a worked example as a recommendation?

No. Examples show how inputs change an outcome. Load one in the calculator and replace its assumptions with your own.

Find the assumption that changes your answer

Run your likely case, then change your move date and the future growth assumptions. Keep enough cash for the costs a model cannot predict.

Open the Rent vs Buy Calculator →

Sources and review notes

Sources reviewed October 16, 2026. These sources support the cost categories and tax cautions. They do not endorse this calculator or supply its illustrative growth assumptions. See our methodology and editorial standards. This guide supports your comparison; it does not replace loan, legal, or tax advice for your situation.